Texas schools board rewrites us history with lessons. Textbook passage referring to slaves as workers prompts. Publishers defer to texas wishes because their statewide market is huge, leading conservatives to push their ideas into the books. Texas students will now learn that slavery was central to the. The enslavement of african americans was the curse of early american life, and texas was no exception. List positive aspects of slavery, texas kids told san antonio, tx after great hearts texas charter school eighth graders were asked to list positive aspects of. Do new texas textbooks whitewash slavery and segregation. After the initial shock i began wondering is this what the. Texas san antonio slavery charter schools san antonio school slavery slavery question in school texas charter school texas school slavery controversy.
State textbook standards on civil war concern historians. American slavery isnt taught well in schools in texas or across the u. The book, with no small boost from oprahs book club, was presented as a game changer. News clips on the texas school book controversy the fox nation. Products of the texas school system have the gablers to thank for the fact that at one point the new deal was axed from the timeline of significant events in american history. Texas schools board rewrites us history with lessons promoting god and guns this article is more than 9 years old us christian conservatives drop references to slave trade and sideline thomas. This high school geography textbook calls slaves workers and immigrants. How texas school board tried to pretend slavery never happened and why your kids school may be next. A diagram of a slave ship superimposed with language from texas new history textbooks via jezebel the september issue of texas monthly reports on. Texas state board of education considers another mexican. Opinion how texas teaches history the new york times. These are questions scholars say are raised by social studies textbooks headed for texas classrooms that. Texas school books whitewash slavery from us history.
The texas board of educations conservative members went on the deep end. How texas school board tried to pretend slavery never. The world geography textbook was used by coby, a student at pearland high school in pearland, tex. The superintendent of the great hearts texas charter school network has apologized after eighthgraders at a san antonio school were given homework asking them to compare the positive aspects and the negative aspects of slavery. Mcgrawhill educations world history textbook referring to african slaves as workers is the latest textbook controversy in texas. In 2016, perspectives reported on the dispute over a mexican. Texas textbook called out as racist against mexicanamericans. Texas controversial social studies textbooks under fire again.
On april 18, a class of eighth graders at the great hearts monte vista north charter school in san antonio, texas, received a homework. The curriculum guidelines prompted many concerns, including that new textbooks would downplay slavery as the cause of the civil war. According to a report in the washington post, the books downplay slavery as a cause of the civil war and barely address segregation in the jim crowera south. Texas school apologizes for asking students to list. Awardwinning journalist, commentator, author of upcoming book the moment how texas school board tried to pretend slavery never happened and why your kids school may be next. Texas revises history education, again perspectives on history. Just look at one of the first mentions of slavery in hmhs texas united states history. This gave the impression that the book committee did not want slavery to be discussed. Middle school students at great hearts monte vista in san antonio were asked to weigh the positive and negative aspects of slavery for an assignment. For 10 years, students in texas have used a history textbook that says not all slaves were unhappy on april 18, a class of eighth graders at the great hearts monte vista north charter school in san. The texas state board of education sboe is no stranger to controversy. This fall, five million public school students in texas began. Texas charter school apologizes for quizzing students on. Texas school asks students to list pros of slavery essence.
Nearly a year after the texas state board of education rejected a mexicanamerican studies textbook proposal opponents called racist, an advocate involved in that fight is. Textbook passage referring to slaves as workers prompts outcry. School books to get rewrite after outcry over slavery. Mcgrawhills inaccurate depiction of slavery is not the first controversy involving texas textbooks. The school boards decrees range from the surreal to the faintly sinister. Texas mother teaches textbook company a lesson on accuracy. Book orders that large tend to influence, if not dictate, what goes onto the pages in those textbooks not just in texas. Students from texas have been using a history textbook. I believe no one can read the history of our country without realizing that the good book and the spirit of the savior have from. Texas social studies textbooks are coming under fire for a photo caption describing slaves as workers who immigrated to the united states.
Heres how new texas public school textbooks write about. Texas will finally teach that slavery was main cause of the civil. Officials with the texas education agency did not respond to requests for comment. New texas textbooks, tailored to state standards that downplay the role of slavery in the civil war and omit mentions of jim crow laws or the ku klux klan, are drawing criticism again as the. American slavery isnt taught well in schools in texas or. Controversial homework assignments have asked students to examine the positive aspects of slavery in american history. Texass latest textbook controversy involves a high school edition of publishing giant mcgrawhills new world geography, in which a caption refers to african slaves who were forcibly brought to. How textbooks can teach different versions of history. How texas inflicts bad textbooks on us by gail collins. The film 12 years a slave depicted the brutality of slavery in america, while a texas textbook whitewashes it, calling slaves workers and immigrants.
Texas schoolbook massacre rewrites american history. Slavery has been upgraded to the primary cause in the curriculum, however states rights and sectionalism will still be taught as contributing. Texas schools board rewrites us history with lessons promoting god and guns. Texas school board approved new history textbooks friday for use across the nations secondlargest state, but only after defeating six and seeing a top publisher withdraw a seventh. Texas textbook calling slaves immigrants to be changed. While the changes were only made to books sold in texas, some feared that the states large market would make the revised texts instant bestsellers, thereby encouraging other school districts to.
American slavery isnt taught well in schools in texas or across. A charter school in texas has apologized after eighthgrade students were asked to list the positive and negative aspects of slavery for an american history class. While the changes were only made to books sold in texas, some feared that the states large market would make the revised texts instant bestsellers. Texas oks most new controversial history textbooks amid. Texas school board approves controversial textbook changes. Textbook publisher mcgrawhill will rewrite part of its world geography book after being accused of whitewashing the role of slavery. Texas textbooks and how they address aspects of history, science, politics and other subjects have been a source of controversy for years in part because the state is one of the largest.
Did texas monthly go too soft on the new texas textbooks. New social studies textbooks planned for use in texas public schools this year are under fire for the way they depict slavery, the civil war and racial segregation. On april 18, a class of eighth graders at the great hearts monte vista north charter school in san antonio, texas, received a homework assignment that would spark a. Npr ed professors, activists and students alike are calling for the texas school board not to approve a. A new report out by the southern poverty law center finds american students dont fully understand many facts about slavery and the role it. The texas state board of education has revised its standards for social studies curriculums in public schools to say that the expansion of. Texas textbook called out as racist against mexican. School apologizes for positive aspects of slavery assignment texas school apologizes for asking students to list positive aspects of slavery would like to send you push. The mexican government was opposed to slavery, but even so, there were 5000 slaves in texas by the time of the texas revolution in 1836. San antonio school responds to assignment asking students. Aaron kindel, the superintendent of the great hearts academies in texas, issued the.
As the one of the largest buyers of textbooks in the country, the board changed and re. Students from texas have been using a history textbook that says. Mcgrawhill education apologises and promises to fix a passage that implies african slaves came to the us as economic migrants. In 2010, the texas board of education approved a socialstudies curriculum that put a conservative stamp on history and economics textbooks, including emphasizing republican political achievements and movements. Heres how new texas public school textbooks write about slavery.
While many teachers forge ahead and actually get it right, one texas charter school had to issue an apology after one of its 8th grade history teachers asked students to find the positive. The publisher of one of texas controversial social studies textbooks has agreed to change a caption that describes african slaves as immigrant workers after a houstonarea moms social. But it will take more than that to fix the way slavery is taught in texas textbooks. Only 8 percent of high school seniors could say slavery was the main cause of the civil war.
The texas state board of education adopted controversial new social studies textbook standards friday, emphasizing the christian influences of the nations founding fathers, highlighting conservative groups and personalities while downplaying liberal ones, and rewriting common terms such as democratic to fall more in line with standards the board. How history textbooks reflect americas refusal to reckon with slavery. Npr ed about 5 million public school students in texas this year will get new and controversial textbooks. A texas school banned the bestselling young adult novel the hate u give, a book inspired by the black lives matter movement. Texas school apologizes for asking students to list positive aspects of slavery. Us history textbooks have been slow to incorporate black humanity in their slavery narratives. Controversial texas textbooks headed to classrooms.
The publisher is working to correct the error, but what does it tell. A texas charter school issued an apology after students were asked to list the positive aspects of slavery. Why calling slaves workers is more than an editing error. A twomonthlong cbs news investigation found problems with how black history is taught across the country and in textbooks.
1123 362 1079 661 421 454 1123 1575 666 1452 1450 1316 982 1002 20 659 135 1465 143 1370 722 1051 1349 497 1366 242 361 25 1310 266 258